When you have different versions of the same song. Peoples opinions will differ...... It's all about musical taste... *Kudos* to all who voiced their opinion. Statistically, it's hard to argue with the Michelle Branch version. She won the Grammy and it was #1 two different times on Billboard..... I don't think Tina Turner is offended, She has plenty of Grammys to dust off on her fireplace mantel. BTW....I love the MB version.