The problem of St. Anger in my opinion it's the duration, with 10 minutes less it would be perfect. I don't get why people hate this sound, it's like garage punk mixed with metal, it was in their intentions and i like the courage they had doing this.
It's a funny cycle that people complaining about the song/album attract people complaining about the people complaining about it. It's a silly notion that people should ONLY be allowed to say that they like or love something. If they don't like it, they have every right to say so. If you take issue with what they say, then say so and explain why; but simply telling them to shut up or ignore it or stop being childish is very silly and leads nowhere. With that being said, this song is pretty bad lyrically but musically it's far from awful. In my opinion, anyway.
Listening to live version from "2006/08/15 Seoul, South Korea". I won't argue that SA is their weakest album, but it sounds pretty good live. They should stop pretending this album doesn't exist and bring back some of these songs.