I think this is the only disappointing song on the album, but only because the demo was so much better...it's just the 'one-take' vocals don't go well with the glossy (but awkward sounding) guitar after the chorus.
I also really prefer the oldest version ! There is a lack of something that I don't manage to describe on this one...It was maybe the demo sound of the 2007 version that gave it this special thing !!! Anyway, great song