Being Held (5:36)

Cover of The For Carnation

From The For Carnation

Track 3 of the eponymous LP The For Carnation (2000) reunited drummer Britt Walford with his former Slint cohort Brian McMahan.

The song notably withholds itself from a final, “Slinty” climax, which frustrated some reviewers expecting that same climax. For example, in its otherwise positive review of the album, Sputnikmusic wrote: :“Being Held” is perhaps most guilty in this respect. This track, exceeding five minutes, starts off with a droning bell-like sound eventually accompanied by a soft drum beat and culminates in a heavier drum beat. The track has no vocals, and is evidently the worst song on the LP. In opposition to an inclination for a solid climax, many will find that the haunting atmosphere and musicianship are more than enough to satisfy.”

While Pitchfork, which gave the record 8/10, wrote: “‘Being Held’ is the undeniable apotheosis of the album; it consists of little more than an insistent bell-like drone, subsonic bass feedback, and a neck-snapping drum solo. That’s all the For Carnation needs to keep you in white- knuckled suspense for 5\xBD minutes.”


Everyone’s tags

More tags

Play with Spotify

Similar Tracks

  Track   Duration Listeners
The For Carnation - A Tribute To 6:09 10,878
June of 44 - Air #17 6:47 10,553
Shipping News - Axons and Dendrites 5:21 247
June of 44 - Shadow Pugilist 3:58 9,444
A Minor Forest - Bill's Mom Likes to Fuck 10:23 3,905
A Minor Forest - Ed Is 50 4:20 3,983

Listening Trend

12,193listeners all time
36,170scrobbles all time
Recent listeners trend:

Explore more


Leave a comment. Log in to or sign up.

Top Listeners