2013: Dead Language by The Flatliners
2012: On the Impossible Past by The Menzingers
2011: Heart Beats Pacific by Banner Pilot
2010: Chamberlain Waits by The Menzingers
2009: Collapser by Banner Pilot
2008: Little Brother by Dead to Me
2007: Four One Five Two by Sundowner
2006: Tie between Unicornography by The Falcon and Oh! Calcutta!. Sorry
Rise Against, but those two albums are masterpieces.
2005: I guess I have to say Searching For a Former Clairty by Against Me! because Cocktails & Dreams by The Lawrence Arms is just a compilation.
2004: Siren Song of the Counter Culture by Rise Against
2003: Revolutions Per Minute by Rise Against
2002: Infiltrate Destroy Rebuild by CKY
2001: Tie between Apathy and Exhaustion by The Lawrence Arms and The Unraveling by Rise Against
2000: Pump Up the Valuum by NOFX