Leave a comment. Log in to Last.fm or sign up (it’s free).
  • Valkyrie13

    Incredible end to a fantastic album. [6]

    March 2015
  • hessel-z

    Incredible end to a fantastic album. [5]

    February 2015
  • theorly64

    Isn't this where... [10] ...we came in? [4]

    November 2014
  • onthewall2983

    Of the three versions I'd probably go with the movie's first, the live one, and the studio version which is a bit too short.

    September 2014
  • Nochek


    August 2014
  • LastOneStand

    Isn't this where...

    March 2014
  • Assedor

    Hybrid of creative material causes extremely soulful melodies. Here appears a deep meaning and intention which is not on the surface.

    December 2013
  • rockandrolljoe


    December 2013
  • twolliebollie

    it's like waters whispering in my left ear this is some creepy shit right here

    June 2013
  • Spiral-Circus

    Incredible end to a fantastic album. [4]

    April 2013
  • P1nkF1oyd

    what does he say at the end?

    March 2013
  • joecubbie

    OMG SAME WITH ME @honkeyreligions!!!!!

    February 2013
  • bolehnemu

    Incredible end to a fantastic album. [3]

    February 2013
  • Dee_Pedro

    The cycle is just pure brilliance. [2]

    December 2012
  • KamalPinkFloyd

    Incredible end to a fantastic album. [2]

    December 2012
  • hokeyreligions

    'Isn't this where -- we came in?' Bloody hell, I've listened to this album about a dozen times yet never put two and two together before now. Chilling.

    June 2012
  • FloydRocks

    I agree with CypheroN. It was my first PF album, but not my fav. Obscured by Clouds...

    May 2012
  • Scantily

    I especially love that choir silently in the background... The Film-version is outstanding as well.

    April 2012
  • mmmojo

    Very good soundtrack of life

    March 2012
  • JackMart

    This is one of those albums that actually finishes at the very end of it: the moment when I realized about the cyclic nature of it ("Isn't this where...?") was actually terrifying... I still feel very strange and somewhat shocked everytime I listen to it. I don't think there's a more involving ending than this.

    January 2012
  • rockandrolljoe

    I don't think its good outside the wall.

    December 2011
  • Yhavimoth

    Oh ok I get it now, history repeats itself. Very clever.

    October 2011
  • Hohko

    Isn't this where... [9] ...we came in? [3]

    October 2011
  • Vascule

    ... we came in? [2]

    August 2011
  • Plaxibo

    Isn't this where... [9]

    July 2011
  • russianvoodoo

    fuck, i've never noticed this thing before. wow.

    June 2011
  • Carmenjb6

    A simple line of "Isn't this where..." changed the entire story and concept of the album. The power of words right there!

    June 2011
  • WichitaQ

    the kids singing in the background really complete the track

    April 2011
  • C_Nunes

    Perfect ending. So peaceful :)

    April 2011
  • toddles822

    Incredible end to a fantastic album.

    February 2011

    :') So sad

    November 2010
  • angelohappier

    no es fácil Golpearse el corazón contra el muro de algún loco. Isn't this where... [8] ... we came in? (2)

    June 2010
  • marthz

    ... we came in?

    June 2010
  • jsnruf

    Isn't this where... [7]

    May 2010
  • WiJoCo

    The album version is great, but the live version from 'Is there anybody out there? the wall live' is fantastic. Although both versions make me feel a bit sad.

    April 2010
  • jamierobertward

    My favourite track from the wall.

    April 2010
  • mariana_

    Isn't this where... [4]

    March 2010
  • Torenkownage

    Outside the Wall from Is There Anybody Out There?: The Wall Live 1980-81 is about 4:27 (4:35 for me). The original album version is much shorter, yes.

    March 2010
  • Zealant


    February 2010
  • nuwahrmahn

    if i'm totally right, yours is the original album one, while that one is the one from the movie.

    December 2009
  • Empty_Skies

    Fantastic ending. Could not be a better ending to one of the best albums ever put together. Ingenious and haunting. This is brilliant.

    October 2009


    August 2009
  • gracz54

    Isn't this where...

    July 2009
  • VoodooChild1108

    very nice ;)

    May 2009
  • Orange1999

    total genius !!

    February 2009
  • LolloBot

    what a sweet song...

    January 2009
  • Blessedheart

    After all, it's not easy banging your heart against some mad bugger's wall.

    October 2008
  • BradyMan

    Isnt this where we came in?

    October 2008
  • Streetee

    How beautiful.

    September 2008
  • cloudpen15

    Ah it cant be over

    September 2008