Have A Cigar (Alternative Version) (7:12)

About this track

This version has Gilmour and Waters on vocals instead of Roy Harper and features slightly different music


Everyone’s tags

More tags

Play with Spotify

We don’t have this track’s album(s) in our catalogue yet.
Labels and artists can upload their music here.

Listening Trend

4,786listeners all time
13,831scrobbles all time
Recent listeners trend:

Explore more


Leave a comment. Log in to Last.fm or sign up.
  • maciejeczko

    As fantastic as original version <3

    7 Nov 2014 Reply
  • Kost1ne


    3 Oct 2013 Reply
  • Baretek8

    Better version

    21 Jun 2013 Reply
  • brunOz_mendes

    There it is, the superior version.

    2 Jun 2012 Reply
  • Cokefloyd

    es un viaje

    5 Apr 2012 Reply
  • JelleAkkermans

    I believe he was having difficulties with his voice. I don't think they chose Harper to sing it because they considered him a better fit, or anything like that. I do prefer the version where it's only Harper singing.

    2 Apr 2012 Reply
  • Spaceman-T

    Listening to this, I can hear no reason why the would substitute Rogers Waters vocal for Roy Harper, It doesn't improve the track in any way?

    18 Mar 2012 Reply

Top Listeners