Please Don't Ask (4:01)

Cover of Duke (Definitive Edition Remaster)

From Duke (Definitive Edition Remaster) and 2 other releases

Know something about this track?
Help build by adding it to the wiki for this track.


Everyone’s tags

More tags

Play with Spotify

Albums featuring this track (3)

Similar Tracks

  Track   Duration Listeners
Genesis - Alone Tonight 3:56 18,978
Genesis - Heathaze 4:59 17,632
Peter Gabriel - Humdrum 3:25 22,819
Peter Gabriel - Moribund The Burgermeister 4:20 22,806
Yes - Without Hope You Cannot Start The Day 5:18 7,415
Yes - Don't Kill the Whale 3:54 24,750

Listening Trend

16,613listeners all time
57,775scrobbles all time
Recent listeners trend:

Explore more


Leave a comment. Log in to or sign up.
  • NaiveAmoeba


    21 Nov 2014 Reply
  • Wizmoe

    I love this track. A personal favourite.

    3 Jan 2012 Reply
  • cartman38

    @XeRocks81 - if you watch one of the classic albums shows that focus on Face Value, Phil does become a little emotional when playing it through on piano.

    23 Apr 2010 Reply
  • DevilDave59

    Stunning, reminds of a love break up i had in 1980

    19 Feb 2010 Reply
  • foxmusicbox

    one of the saddest, but also one of the most memorable songs by Collins.

    22 Aug 2009 Reply
  • therabidwombat

    We probably would never have had this song if Gabriel had stayed in the band...this song is one of the reasons why I love both Phil and Peter as lead singers/frontmen of the band.

    22 Oct 2008 Reply
  • Calenthe

    Yess. The most sad song of Genesis.

    11 Feb 2008 Reply

    Im sure Phil was holding back the tears when he was recording this song. I had a bad break up once. When i use to listen to the Duke cd. I had to skip this song !!

    2 Feb 2008 Reply
  • XeRocks81

    possibly the most personal song Phil's ever written. To this day he can't sing it without becoming emotional.

    19 May 2007 Reply

Top Listeners