The Cupid's Got a Shotgun Songfacts reports that when Carrie performed this romp during a Live on Letterman mini concert, she admitted that it’s a little out of character and her husband, Mike Fisher, questioned it the first time she let him listen to the tune.
Oh he gave up on arrows a long, long time ago
Turns out I'm too hard to hit so he put away his bow
I might just keep on running from here to Timbuktu
'Cause he gave up on arrows and I ain't bulletproof