Anberlin – Naïve Orleans (4:07)

nDroae

The only possibility I can think of is... I know that I listened to my Recommendations radio very early on (I first became active just before November 2006 so October would fit) and Paperthin Hymn came on, I was like "Oh so THIS song is by Anberlin!" and I definitely remember hitting Love. So it was my first loved track (and not undeservedly so), but apparently Lastfm misplaced that data as my love history shows that I loved Paperthin Hymn July 2008. I also can see from my email archives that I bought both NTFP and Cities March 2007, and didn't get BFTBM until October 2007. I sharply recall that BFTBM, though good, was one of my first experiences with hipsters giving me bad advice about older albums being superior.