Pink Floyd is not prog! It is primitive!

Iscriviti Condividi

10 iscritti| 93 messaggi in bacheca

Leader: Nessuno! (Vuoi candidarti come leader? Consulta la sezione Gruppi della Guida per scoprire cosa puoi fare).
Criteri di appartenenza: Aperto
Data creazione: 29 Ott 2009
Pink Floyd IS NOT PROG!!
If you listen to Pink Floyd and think that this band or similar ones are progressive, you are WRONG!! PF is primitive shit.

True progressive bands like Gentle Giant, King Crimson, etc. make complex music. PF and pf-influenced bands, self-claimed "neoprog" ,spoiled the term in millions of minds. We are against this! True prog listeners welcome)

for ones who don't understand,

PINK FLOYD (of course i'm talking about later stuff) = PRIMITIVE

Artisti più ascoltati della settimana

Nessuna classifica per il gruppo. Le classifiche dei gruppi vengono calcolate ogni settimana per i gruppi con più di 2 iscritti.


Aggiungi un commento. Accedi a o registrati.
  • aggroroofer

    Progressive music deviates from conventional songwriting patterns, it doesn't have to be overly complex...

    15 Gen 2012 Rispondi
  • tribaltyn


    24 Lug 2010 Rispondi
  • megajosh2

    Whoever made this group has too limited a view of what progressive rock is.

    14 Mag 2010 Rispondi
  • FacelessShadows

    Though I'll admit I don't like the fact that heaps of newer Progressive Rock bands seem to exclusively base themselves upon Pink Floyd

    16 Mar 2010 Rispondi
  • FacelessShadows

    Wow, musical snobbery on, so surprising.

    16 Mar 2010 Rispondi
  • sobreviviente11

    I agree that Pink Floyd is less progressive than KC or GG, but progressivity doesn't mean only complexity of composition. Progressive means also using new techniques, instruments, combining instruments and styles that haven't been combined before (Atom Heart Mother? hello?). And, maybe the most important, ambitious attitude for making music. Long compositions, concept albums, influences from surrealistic music and classic (aleatoric, to be specific). And for the love of no-god - PF commited only two questionable albums - Momentary Lapse Of Reason and Division Bell (and maybe Final Cut), and they are NOT known and worshipped for THESE works, so this group is just stupid, although I totally agree that neo-prog like Marillion is crap, and listening to them makes me vomit.

    26 Feb 2010 Rispondi
  • Barely-A-Vapor

    This group is just stupid... [3]

    26 Feb 2010 Rispondi
  • Equality7-2521

    This group is just stupid... [2]

    25 Gen 2010 Rispondi
  • gabrielcavaresi


    15 Gen 2010 Rispondi
  • Matzomixxx

    gogitosbanditos. i stopped reading your bullshit when you said Britney is better than pink floyd ... and i dont really think you know what progressive means

    15 Gen 2010 Rispondi
  • M-Phase-I-Saw

    "Of course I'm talking about later stuff." <- How about putting a bit more emphasis on that? Still, I won't let music like their four big albums be called "primitive" as in flat or uninspired. I admit, personally, I've defined the prog genre via its complex rhythm and virtuoso use of sound spectra for a long time. But I've come to look at those artists as expressionists of their complexity within, which may also include simple sound patterns (such as ELP's "Lucky Man"). To me, the Floyd's early works reflected a true spirit of experimentalism and virtuosity. Technique is only as authentic as the spirit beneath it.

    6 Gen 2010 Rispondi
  • kissesneverdie

    Are the Ramones "prog"? =p

    1 Gen 2010 Rispondi
  • RaditAndrogyny

    This group is just stupid...

    23 Dic 2009 Rispondi
  • UserNameMissing

    Hello! Prog rock is not only ''complex music''. It's also about lyrics, variety of instruments, different song structures (doesn't have to mean thousands of different time signatures) and so on... Probably nothing new here, but just had to say something...Thank you.

    16 Dic 2009 Rispondi
  • Lucifer-Sam

    atom heart mother

    10 Dic 2009 Rispondi
  • Morkburger


    5 Dic 2009 Rispondi
  • Jiffy_No0b

    This isn't how genres work.

    1 Dic 2009 Rispondi
  • shlshred

    Lady Gaga and Ramones are on the charts! what a prog group!

    30 Nov 2009 Rispondi
  • harsh_vs

    agreee with Olav!! Its simply stupid.. dumb cunt! :D

    29 Nov 2009 Rispondi
  • OlavOrganist

    That's just stupid. Also, nice charts for a "tr00 prog"-group.

    27 Nov 2009 Rispondi
  • Tutti i messaggi (93)